AddComment does not post, preview, or cancel.

[aaron@…]

When I click Add Comment, Preview, or Cancel, it attempts to load, e.g. /wiki/MyWikiPage#commentpreview and there is simply a "Create this page" button, nothing else.

I've just upgraded to 0.10.1dev; if it is a configuration issue, no such indications were given on the hack's description page.

[jose.junior@…]

Same behavior here using 0.10.

[Alec Thomas]

Works for me using 0.10.3. This could have been an artifact of the CSRF protection.

[Harald Radi]

would have been nice but still doesn't work for me

see ​http://harald.fluffnstuff.org/wiki/test

[Noah Kantrowitz]

Replying to harald:

would have been nice but still doesn't work for me

see ​http://harald.fluffnstuff.org/wiki/test

Did you modify the macro at all? It seems to be using POSTs where it should be using GETs.

[Harald Radi]

egbert:/home/harald/trac-stuff/addcommentmacro/0.10# svn up At revision 1851. egbert:/home/harald/trac-stuff/addcommentmacro/0.10# svn status ? build ? TracAddCommentMacro.egg-info ? temp

therefore no :)

I'm running trac on an apache webserver using mod_python, could this somehow interfere?

[eric@…]

Yes, the code in svn (as of r1855) is using 'post' as the method.

Changing the method='post' to method='get' has solved the problem for me. (on 0.10.3)

[Harald Radi]

Verified. Changing the method from post to get worked for me too.

[paul@…]

Switching from post to get might fix the code, but it is definitely not an appropriate use of HTTP GET.

​http://www.w3.org/2001/tag/doc/whenToUseGet.html

[eric@…]

Replying to paul@prescod.net:

Switching from post to get might fix the code, but it is definitely not an appropriate use of HTTP GET.

Agreed. People can (and do) reload a page and double post a comment. Does anybody have a better fix yet? Thanks.

[Noah Kantrowitz]

Please upgrade to the latest version. This should pull in the MacroPostPlugin, which will fix the issue.